1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

DIR : Minimum Gas : Avoiding the "oh crap" moment

Discussion in 'DIR Diving' started by Gareth Burrows, Oct 11, 2010.

  1. Gareth Burrows

    Gareth Burrows Super Moderator
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    Aug 2, 2010
    Messages:
    1,053
    Likes Received:
    473
    Seeing a diver who has run out of gas is extremely frightening. You are aware you are looking at someone who is moments away from drowning. Actually being that person must be beyond terrifying and out the other side.

    As DIR divers, this is something we like to avoid, so I thought I'd post the DIR take on gas management - how much gas we reserve for safety. some people say leave the bottom with 50 bar. some people say hit the surface with 50 bar. DIR divers work out how much they need for any given depth, and keep that in reserve

    There are two concepts to consider

    Minimum Gas
    The DIR concept of “minimum gas” is the unbreakable rule by which we plan our dives. Minimum gas represents the minimum amount of gas carried by each diver that will allow the diver to get themselves, and another diver, to the next available gas source. For a short shallow dive, this might mean a direct ascent to the surface. For a longer dive with mandatory decompression stops, this might mean the ascent to a depth where it becomes appropriate to switch to another gas. Minimum gas is an absolute. It is never violated during the bottom portion of the dive, and once minimum gas is reached, the only option is to call the dive and ascend immediately.

    Gas Rules
    This is how we plan our gas to be used. Let’s say our minimum gas is 70 Bar in our twinset, and we start the dive with 220 bar. That means we have 150 bar of usable gas. With that 150 bar, we then apply a gas rule. That rule might be thirds (when the dive MUST return to a starting point), halves (when it would be useful for the diver to return to the start point but not essential) or all useable gas (where the diver can just ascend from wherever they are and be picked up). The “All useable gas” rule is often applied in UK waters where the boat can just come and get us, but we might apply halves if the skipper wants us to return to a shotline. The beauty of the gas rules is that if we get back to our starting point early, and ahead of minimum gas, we can just recalculate our halves, or thirds, and go off again.

    Calculating Minimum Gas

    The fundamantal principle. At all times, a DIR diver enough gas to get themselves, and a team mate , to the next available gas source.

    OK, so in order to know how much gas we have available for the dive, and in order to know our safety factor, we have to be able to calculate minimum gas. I’m going to run through two examples, a thirty metre dive where we can ascend directly to the surface, and a 45 metre dive, where we have to ascend to 21M to do a gas switch

    30 Metre Dive

    To calculate min deco, we make several assumptions.

    • Firstly, we assume an ascent rate of 9M per minute to 50% of the depth, then 3 Metres per minute after that.
    • Secondly, we assume a SAC rate of 30 Litres per minute for both divers. This might seem high to some people. But, in an incident, SAC rate can hit 100. Even if it then settles down, it’s going to average out significantly higher than your normal rate
    • We assume one minute at the bottom sorting out whatever has gone wrong and getting moving

    So, here we are at thirty metres, and all hell breaks loose so two divers have to ascend directly to the surface on one diver’s backgas.

    50% of 30m = 15 metres
    So, from the bottom

    1 Minute resolving Issue
    2 Minutes to get from 30M to 15M (plan on 9m/min but most people achieve around 7m/min)
    1 Minute to get from 15M to 12M
    1 Minute to get from 12M to 9M
    1 Minute to get from 9M to 6M
    1 Minute to get from 6M to 3M
    1 Minute to get from 3M to the surface

    This means a 8 minute ascent time.

    Now we need to know the average depth. For the dive above, I would call the average depth 10 Metres or 2 Bar

    8 minutes of Gas for 2 divers = 16 minutes of Gas required
    Depth consumption Rate = 2 Bar X 30 Litres = 60 Litres Per minute

    16 X 60 = 960 Litres of Gas Required

    Therefore minimum gas for this dive would be 960 litres of gas, or 80 bar in a single 12 cylinder.

    So, on a 30 metre dive, with both divers using a single 12, we know we need to leave the bottom before we hit 80 bar to ensure that if there is a total loss of gas for one diver, we can safely and slowly ascend to the surface. This might be far more conservative than other measures due to the slow ascent rate, but it is very comforting to know we can ascend at this rate and still know we have enough gas.

    If we have a 220 bar fill in a single 12, and are going to be picked up by the boat, this gives us 140 bar to use during the dive which is nice.

    Some people might find the maths a little baffling, but others might just see it immediately. Once you run a few of them through your head you can do it simply enough. We would do this before we hit the water if it was a known depth, or at the bottom of the shotline if it was different than expected.

    Now, these figures are always the same, so you could work out the min gas required for each depth, or write them on a slate. However, this defeats the true strength of the calculation, and it is strongly encouraged that DIR divers learn to do this in their heads. Here’s the reason. Let’s say you reach the seabed, and the depth is shallower or deeper than you planned, you can just recalculate minimum gas on the spot and make the most of the gas you have with you without risking safety. That last factor is the real winner for me, and the calculation is simple enough after a while.

    Let’s take the calculation a little deeper, shall we say 45 metres?


    45 Metre Dive

    On this dive, we are at 45M and we are carrying a stage of 50%. Remember that Minimum gas is supposed to get you and another dive to the next available gas source, which in this case is 21M where we would switch to the 50%.

    We use the same SAC of 30 Litres Per minute.

    80% of the ATAs in this case is 34 metres, but we deal in multiple of 3 metres, so we will call it 33 metres.

    This, then is the ascent profile

    1 minute at 45 resolving issue
    2 minutes to get from 45 to 33 (more than 9 metres per min so has to be 2)
    1 minute to get from 33 to 30
    1 minute to get from 30 to 27
    1 minute to get from 27 to 24
    1 minute to get from 24 to 21
    1 minute to allow for gas switch

    This gives us an 8 minute ascent until we are on the next gas source.

    Now we need to know the average depth. For the dive above, I would call the average depth 33 Metres or 4.3 Bar.

    The calculation, then…

    8 minutes of Gas for 2 divers = 16 minutes of Gas required
    Depth consumption Rate = 4.3 Bar X 30 Litres = 129 Litres Per minute

    16 X 129 = 2064 Litres of Gas Required.

    In a set of twin 12s this would equate to 86 bar. Again, we will round this up to be 90 bar. Assuming a 220 bar fill, and again using the gas rule of all available gas, this means we have 130 bar of gas to play with before we have to leave the bottom.

    So that’s minimum gas a la DIR.

    Remember that you “could” always get up a lot faster than this, but why not plan for a nice controlled, slow ascent, rather than planning for a race up to the surface.

    In addition, the numbers here are exact, but in the case of a different bottom depth, it would be advisable to use easier numbers e.g. 4.5 instead of 4.3.

    Finally, as the depths increase, the time spent at 1.5x your normal SAC during the ascent is not realistic and also becomes penalising and so those DIR divers doing Tech 2+ depths use a different average SAC rate than 1.5x

    Finally, just a reminder of the Golden Rule

    At all times during a dive, we carry enough gas to get ourselves, and a buddy or team mate, to the next available gas source. This rule is never violated.

    Hope this has been useful to someone

    G
     
    jps likes this.
  2. Suggsy

    Suggsy Banned

    Joined:
    Jan 25, 2008
    Messages:
    3,041
    Likes Received:
    320
    Is there and easy way of calculating the average depth for the ascent required?
     
  3. Gareth Burrows

    Gareth Burrows Super Moderator
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    Aug 2, 2010
    Messages:
    1,053
    Likes Received:
    473
    just half the distance between the bottom and the next gas source and then round it to make it easy. If you are at 31 metres going to the surface, use 15. If you are at 49 and going to 21, use 35
     
  4. Bobco

    Bobco Active Member

    Joined:
    Jan 17, 2008
    Messages:
    2,592
    Likes Received:
    22
    A very understandable post Gareth, very similar to how I plan now, and the deeper the dive the more carefully this needs to be done. Plan the dive, and dive the plan.
     
  5. old salty sea dog

    old salty sea dog New Member

    Joined:
    Oct 11, 2010
    Messages:
    11
    Likes Received:
    0
    Plan the dive, Dive the plan, these were the words of the great hal watts who pioneered deep air and set deep air records, he also started PSAI for those that dont know
     
  6. jb2cool

    jb2cool Moderator
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    Jan 20, 2008
    Messages:
    3,178
    Likes Received:
    498
    I was linking to this from another thread and though I've better answer this question

    Start depth + finish depth divided by 2

    So using Garf's examples;
    31 + 0 = 31 divided by 2 = 15.5 average
    49 + 21 = 70 divided by 2 = 35 average
     
  7. Vanny

    Vanny Active Member

    Joined:
    Apr 18, 2016
    Messages:
    598
    Likes Received:
    200
    I’m a bit tick but how do you get a finish depth at 21? Is it first stop depth or summing?
     
  8. Vanny

    Vanny Active Member

    Joined:
    Apr 18, 2016
    Messages:
    598
    Likes Received:
    200
    Apologies got it now, reading the thread backwards.

    Maybe it’s just me but that original post is 8 years old and feels a bit condescending , DIR this that and the other. Interesting that agencies prescribing to the DIR concept don’t tend to mention DIR that much nowadays. It’s more agency xyz do it this way.
     
  9. jb2cool

    jb2cool Moderator
    Staff Member

    Joined:
    Jan 20, 2008
    Messages:
    3,178
    Likes Received:
    498
    It might just be the way it's written (Garf is pretty matter of fact) but when you are calculating minimum gas it's very important that it's correct as this could be someone's life on the line. GUE teach a specific way or working out minimum gas and they have certain rules/procedures so that if you are diving with GUE trained buddies (even people you've never met before) you'll all be singing off the same songsheet.

    You are right that the DIR acronynm is not used as much these days, it did carry a bit of bad press with it back in the day along the lines of "I don't dive DIR does that mean I'm doing it wrong? Who the f##k are you to say I'm wrong" so the GUE training is just branded as being under the GUE banner these days but it's the same stuff.
     
    Vanny likes this.

Share This Page

  • About Us

    Our UKDivers community has been around for many years and prides itself on offering unbiased, helpful discussion among people of all disciplines and abilities. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best and friendliest around.
  • Support us!

    The management works very hard to make sure the community continues to run reliably. Care to support us? All donations go to the running costs of the forum: hosting charges, software maintenance, etc. We'd really appreciate it!

    Choose option:  

    UKD Username: